Skip to content

AthenaHQ alternative: how PromptMentions compares

PromptMentions, which we make, is an alternative to AthenaHQ for brands and small agencies that want a lower-priced paid plan. AthenaHQ has a free Essential plan with 300 credits, then Starter at $295 a month. PromptMentions has no free plan; it starts at $49 a month after a 7-day free trial. AthenaHQ offers a free plan and eleven AI models, which PromptMentions does not.

We make PromptMentions. Everything said here about AthenaHQ comes from its own website, checked on 15 November 2026, and each fact links to the page it came from. Prices change, so check AthenaHQ's own pricing before you buy.

AthenaHQ and PromptMentions: side-by-side comparison

What is comparedAthenaHQPromptMentions
Who it suitsAnyone who wants to look around on a free plan first.Teams that have outgrown a free plan and find $295 a month too steep.
PriceEssential is free. Starter is $295 a month. Enterprise is priced on request.Source, checked 15 November 2026$49, $149 or $299 a month. Paying yearly costs ten months instead of twelve.
Free trial or free planA free Essential plan with 300 credits.Source, checked 15 November 20267-day free trial. A card is needed; nothing is charged before the trial ends.
AI assistants coveredEssential: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot. Starter covers 11 models, adding Google AI Mode, Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral.Source, checked 15 November 2026ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok and Meta AI, plus Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode and the ChatGPT app (captured). All on every plan; one schedule runs up to 4 of them. Copilot on Bing is paused for now.
How answers are collectedNot stated on its websiteChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok and Meta AI through each company's own service. Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode are captured from the results page, and the ChatGPT app (captured) from the ChatGPT app itself, for one place at one time: the search pages in 10 countries, the ChatGPT app in 43. Every answer is labelled with how it was collected.
Saved AI answers you can openNot stated on its websiteEvery answer is saved in full, with the assistant, the model, the country, the date and the exact question, and opens from any number in a report.
What a plan includesSold as credits: one credit is one AI answer. Starter includes 3,600 credits a month.Source, checked 15 November 2026217, 650 or 2,165 answers a month, by plan. One answer is one AI assistant answering one of your questions.
Brands or clientsNot stated on its website1, 3 or 10 brands or clients, each in its own project.
Team membersUnlimited users on every plan, with role-based access on Starter and Enterprise.Source, checked 15 November 2026Unlimited on every plan, with owner, editor and viewer roles.
Client access and rolesRole-based access control on Starter and Enterprise; the roles are not named.Source, checked 17 November 2026Owner, editor and viewer roles for your team; a viewer can read but not change anything, and an owner can limit a viewer to chosen clients. A client gets a read-only link to their own report that opens without a sign-in and can be withdrawn.
For agenciesThe Enterprise plan is described as for enterprises and agencies.Source, checked 15 November 2026A separate project for each client, your logo on reports, and client report links that open without a sign-in.
Help fixing what it findsContent recommendations on the free plan; Starter adds on-page and off-page actions and a content optimisation agent.Source, checked 15 November 2026Tasks with the AI answer attached, briefs from approved facts, drafts, approval of one exact version, and delivery to WordPress as a draft. Webflow, HubSpot and Contentful can also receive drafts.
Exports and connectionsCSV export on Starter. API access is a paid add-on. Enterprise adds single sign-on and dashboards for Tableau, Power BI and Looker.Source, checked 15 November 2026CSV export, printable reports, Slack alerts, signed webhooks, a Looker Studio connector, a read-only API and an MCP connection on every plan. AI crawler logs show which AI bots read your pages.

"Not stated on its website" means we could not find it on AthenaHQ's public pages on the date shown. It does not mean the feature is missing.

Who each one suits

AthenaHQ suits

  • Anyone who wants to look around on a free plan first.
  • Teams that need DeepSeek or Mistral.
  • Enterprises that need single sign-on and dashboards in Tableau, Power BI or Looker.

PromptMentions suits

  • Teams that have outgrown a free plan and find $295 a month too steep.
  • Agencies with 3 to 10 clients, each in its own project with a branded report.
  • Teams that want API access included in the plan rather than sold as an add-on.

AthenaHQ pricing, plan limits and free options

AthenaHQ and PromptMentions prices side by side, as listed on 15 November 2026

AthenaHQ

  • Essential: free. 300 credits, 5 AI models, unlimited users.Source, checked 15 November 2026
  • Starter: $295 a month. 3,600 credits, 11 AI models, CSV export. API access and extra credits cost more.Source, checked 15 November 2026
  • Enterprise: priced on request. Single sign-on, an activity log, persona targeting and executive dashboards.Source, checked 15 November 2026

PromptMentions

  • One brand: $49 a month, with 217 answers a month.
  • Up to 3 brands or clients: $149 a month, with 650 answers a month.
  • Up to 10 brands or clients: $299 a month, with 2,165 answers a month.

Every feature and every AI engine is on every plan, and paying yearly costs ten months instead of twelve. See what each plan includes

Best options by team and budget

AthenaHQ alternatives fall into a few groups.

  • Free to start: AthenaHQ's Essential plan, 300 credits and five AI models.
  • Small paid budget: PromptMentions Solo at $49, OtterlyAI or Rankscale, all well under AthenaHQ Starter at $295.
  • Agencies with 3 to 10 clients: PromptMentions, each client in its own project with unlimited team members.
  • Enterprises: AthenaHQ Enterprise, Profound or Scrunch, priced on request.

Pricing models and real costs

AthenaHQ is credit-based: one credit is one AI answer, and Starter includes 3,600 credits a month for $295. PromptMentions counts the same thing and calls it an answer.

PromptMentions counts answers: one AI assistant answering one of your questions is one answer. Solo includes 217 answers a month for $49, enough for about 10 questions every week on four AI engines, the most one schedule runs. The 3-client plan includes 650 ($149, about 32 questions a week) and the 10-client plan 2,165 ($299, about 108 questions a week), shared across your clients.

Credit-based and flat monthly plans compare fairly once you turn both into answers a month. AthenaHQ Starter holds more answers than any PromptMentions plan; PromptMentions costs less and includes every feature, API access among them, on every plan. On AthenaHQ, API access is a paid add-on.

Tracking versus help implementing changes

AthenaHQ gives content recommendations on its free plan, and Starter adds on-page and off-page actions and a content optimisation agent. PromptMentions turns each gap into a task with the AI answer attached, writes a brief from approved facts, drafts the page and lets a person approve one exact version before it goes to WordPress as a draft.

Evaluation criteria and feature verification

Vendor pages, including ours, describe features in their best light. Check each claim during a trial: open the saved answer behind a number, run the same question twice, and see which features are on the plan you would actually buy rather than only on Enterprise.

Free options and trials

AthenaHQ's free plan is ongoing tracking with a small allowance. PromptMentions has no free plan: its 7-day trial needs a card and charges nothing until it ends, and its free tools are one-off checks with no account. OtterlyAI's 7-day trial needs no card.

What PromptMentions does differently

One simple price list

Three plans from $49 a month. Every feature and every AI assistant is on every plan, including the trial. Plans differ only by how many brands or clients you add and how much you can run each month, and both are written on the pricing page.

Made for client work

Each brand or client is its own project, with its own questions, answers, tasks and report. Reports carry your logo, a client can open their own report from a read-only link with no sign-in, and every plan includes unlimited team members.

Every answer is kept as proof

PromptMentions saves each AI answer in full, with the assistant, the date, the country and the exact question. When a client or a manager asks "where did that number come from?", you open the answer and show them.

From the gap to the fix in one place

A gap becomes a task with the AI answer attached. You write a brief from facts you have approved, draft the page, approve one exact version and send it to WordPress as a draft. Nothing is published without a person saying yes.

Other AthenaHQ alternatives at a glance, and who each suits

ToolBest forStarting price
Peec AIMarketing teams that want daily checks read from the chat appsFrom $95 a monthSource, checked 20 November 2026
ProfoundLarge companies buying through a sales teamNo public price; a quote after a demoSource, checked 20 November 2026
OtterlyAISmall teams that want the lowest monthly priceFrom $29 a monthSource, checked 20 November 2026
ScrunchLarger brands that want to serve AI agents directlyFrom $250 a monthSource, checked 15 November 2026
Semrush AI Visibility ToolkitTeams already paying for Semrush$99 a month for one domainSource, checked 15 November 2026
Ahrefs Brand RadarTeams already on Ahrefs who want to look up any brand at onceIncluded in small amounts with a paid Ahrefs plan; the AI index starts at $199 a monthSource, checked 15 November 2026
RankscaleAgencies with many brands and a tight budgetFrom $17 a month, billed yearlySource, checked 15 November 2026
PromptwatchTeams that want content written and published for themFrom $95 a monthSource, checked 15 November 2026
RankabilityAgencies that also sell content optimisation and auditsFrom $97 a monthSource, checked 17 November 2026

What AthenaHQ offers that PromptMentions does not

  • A free plan, so you can look around without a card.Source, checked 15 November 2026
  • Eleven AI models on the Starter plan, including DeepSeek and Mistral.Source, checked 15 November 2026
  • Enterprise features such as single sign-on, an activity log and dashboards for Tableau, Power BI and Looker.Source, checked 15 November 2026

We are newer and smaller, and we say so: PromptMentions tops out at 10 brands or clients per plan, runs up to four AI engines on one schedule, captures Google's AI answers in 10 countries only (Copilot on Bing is paused for now), and its trial needs a card.

Testing tools before you commit: what to check in a free trial

A trial is only useful if you test the same thing in each tool. Run AthenaHQ and any alternative side by side for a week or two, and check these before you pay.

  • Put the same 10 to 20 customer questions into each tool, in the same country and language, in the same week.
  • Run each question more than once. AI answers change from run to run, so a single run proves very little.
  • Open the saved answer behind a number. If you cannot read the full answer and its links, you cannot check the number.
  • Check a few answers by hand: is your brand named where the tool says it is, and are the cited links right?
  • Export the data to CSV, or try the API, and make sure you could take it with you.
  • Work out what one month of your questions would use, in the unit the tool sells: prompts, credits or answers.

Switching from AthenaHQ without losing useful data

Different tools collect AI answers in different ways, so their numbers will never match exactly. Plan the move so that a change of tool is not mistaken for a change in AI visibility.

  • Export your prompts and past results from AthenaHQ before the plan ends.
  • Add the same questions to the new tool, word for word, with the same country and language. PromptMentions can import a list of questions.
  • Run both tools for two to four weeks. The overlap shows how far apart their numbers are.
  • Compare trends over weeks, not single numbers. A jump on the day you switch is usually the tool, not the AI answers.
  • Keep the old exports with your past reports, so earlier months can still be explained.

Reporting and revenue measurement: what tracking can and cannot prove

AI visibility tracking shows how often your brand is named and linked when AI assistants answer your customers' questions. On its own it does not show sales. Some visits from AI assistants appear in your analytics as referrals from sites such as chatgpt.com or perplexity.ai, but many answers lead to no click at all, so a mention can shape a buyer's shortlist without leaving any trace in your CRM.

Report the two side by side: visibility from the tracker, and referral visits and leads from your analytics, read together over months rather than days. PromptMentions reports show the saved answers and the number of answers behind each rate, and the app connects to Google Search Console for search data.

Questions

How much does AthenaHQ cost?

AthenaHQ has a free Essential plan with 300 credits. Its Starter plan is $295 a month with 3,600 credits, and Enterprise is priced on request. PromptMentions costs $49, $149 or $299 a month.

Is there a cheaper alternative to AthenaHQ?

For a paid plan, yes: PromptMentions starts at $49 a month, and OtterlyAI, Rankscale, Peec AI and Promptwatch all start under $295. AthenaHQ also has a free plan with a small allowance.

What is a credit, and how does PromptMentions count usage?

AthenaHQ counts one credit for each AI answer. PromptMentions counts the same thing and calls it an answer sample: one answer from one AI assistant to one of your questions. Each plan states how many you get a month.

Does PromptMentions have an API?

Yes. Every plan includes a read-only API and an MCP connection for your own dashboards and AI tools.

Which AthenaHQ alternatives are best for small teams, agencies and enterprises?

Small teams: PromptMentions, OtterlyAI or Rankscale. Agencies: PromptMentions or Rankscale. Enterprises: Profound, Scrunch or AthenaHQ Enterprise.

Which AthenaHQ alternatives are cheaper for the same tracking workload?

Turn the workload into answers a month. Peec AI, Promptwatch and Scrunch include several thousand answers on their first plans. PromptMentions includes 217 on Solo, so it is cheaper for a small, weekly workload and not for a large daily one.

How do credit-based plans compare with flat monthly pricing?

A credit is usually one answer from one AI assistant. Divide the plan price by the answers it holds and compare that, with the features you need.

Which AI engines are included in each entry-level plan?

AthenaHQ Essential: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot. PromptMentions: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Meta AI, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode and the ChatGPT app (captured) on every plan.

Which tools support multiple clients, languages and markets?

PromptMentions keeps each client in its own project and sets the country and language per question set. AthenaHQ describes Enterprise as for enterprises and agencies.

When is switching worthwhile rather than keeping my current platform?

When the next plan up costs more than the work is worth to you, or when you need something the current one lacks, such as client projects or saved answers.

More comparisons

Peec AI alternatives
From $49 a month against $95, with every AI assistant included and a way to fix what you find.
Profound alternatives
Published prices from $49 a month and a self-serve trial, where Profound quotes after a demo.
Otterly AI alternatives
A fix-it workflow and saved answers, against OtterlyAI's lower starting price.
Scrunch AI alternative
From $49 a month with nine AI engines, against $250 a month for four.
Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit alternative
Your own questions, Claude and Perplexity included, from $49 a month against $99 for one domain.
Ahrefs Brand Radar alternative
A stand-alone tracker for your own questions, with no Ahrefs subscription needed.
Rankscale alternative
A fix-it workflow and plain allowances, against Rankscale's lower prices and wider engine list.
Promptwatch alternative
From $49 a month against $95, with 3 clients for $149.
Rankability alternative
A dedicated AI mention tracker from $49 a month, against $97 for a content and tracking bundle.
Best AI visibility tools
Ten tools side by side: starting price, free trial, AI assistants covered and who each suits.
Best GEO and AEO tools
GEO tools compared on the AI engines they track, trials, and whether they help fix what they find.
Best AI visibility tools for agencies
Eight tools compared on what an agency pays for: client projects, team seats, client access and branded reports.
Best GEO tools for freelance SEO consultants
Seven tools for a consultant with a few clients: client projects, team members, trials and price.
Peec AI vs Profound vs Otterly AI
One table for the three best-known trackers and PromptMentions: prices, AI engines, limits, seats and trials.

Guides

Try PromptMentions beside AthenaHQ

Add your website, save a few customer questions and read the first AI answers in minutes. Then judge for yourself.

Start free trial

Free for 7 days. Card required, cancel anytime. See pricing

Not ready for a trial? The brand mention analyser shows how an AI answer you paste in treats your brand, free and with no account.